Concetti Chiave
- The "War Poets" express contrasting views on war and patriotism, with Rupert Brooke showing strong patriotism and Wilfred Owen highlighting the futility of war.
- Wilfred Owen's work challenges early 20th-century ideals of patriotism, a sentiment echoed in later works examining the complex nature of war.
- Michael Morpurgo's "Private Peaceful" questions the fairness of punishing soldiers like Tommy Peaceful, who refuse to fight, as cowards and traitors.
- Contemporary media coverage of wars offers a sense of proximity, yet writers and artists still feel compelled to critically respond to war events.
- The play "In Conflict" presents real stories of American veterans, exploring motives for joining the army and the challenges faced after serving.
The changing face of war and patriotism
The "War Poets", or soldier poets, describe their experiences of fighting in the Great War in very different ways. Rupert Brooke's The Soldier shows the author's strong sense of patriotism, while Herbert Read in The Happy Warrior treats a horrific moment of trench warfare when a British soldier stabs a "well-killed"German soldier. In Futility Wilfred Owen explores the sense of waste and meaninglessness that the death of a fellow soldier arouses in him.
The ideals of patriotism and the duty to fight for one's country expressed in Brooke's poem were widespread in the early part of the 20th century, and questioned by only a minority of the population, one of whom was Wilfred Owen; instead this point of view finds support in many late 20th-century works embodying very different takes on war and patriotism. In his novel Private Peaceful (2003), Michael Morpourgo charts the experience of a young , working-class soldier in World War I. When Private Tommy Peaceful is no longer prepared to fight for his country, he is court martialled and executed. Peaceful was treated as a coward and a traitor by the British Government at the time, and, in this novel Morpourgo asks whether this punishment was fair and just.Today wars receive extensive media and press coverage, with the result that we may feel we are well informed and we might even feel as if we had visited the war zones. Even so its still crucial for contemporary writers and visual artists to respond to events. They are often motivated by a sense of shame and indignation that their government has gone to war. The American play In Conflict (2008), devised and directed by Douglas Gagier, dramatizes the real-life stories of a group of American army veterans who fought for their country in Afghanistan and Iraq. As each character tells his or her story, audience members hear how unemployment, poverty, boredom, hope for a different life, persuaded these men an women to join up and fight for their country. The veterans also tell us why they left the army; some suffered from depression and suicidal feelings, others were injured, others grew disenchanted with the job, etc.
Domande da interrogazione
- ¿Cómo se representa el patriotismo en la poesía de guerra?
- ¿Qué cuestiona Michael Morpurgo en su novela "Private Peaceful"?
- ¿Qué motiva a los escritores y artistas contemporáneos a responder a los eventos de guerra?
En la poesía de guerra, el patriotismo se representa de manera diversa. Rupert Brooke en "The Soldier" muestra un fuerte sentido de patriotismo, mientras que Wilfred Owen en "Futility" cuestiona el sentido de la guerra y la muerte, reflejando una visión más crítica.
Michael Morpurgo cuestiona la justicia del castigo recibido por el soldado Tommy Peaceful, quien fue ejecutado por negarse a seguir luchando, planteando interrogantes sobre el trato a los soldados considerados cobardes o traidores.
Los escritores y artistas contemporáneos a menudo se sienten motivados por un sentido de vergüenza e indignación hacia las decisiones de sus gobiernos de ir a la guerra, lo que los impulsa a crear obras que reflejan las experiencias y consecuencias de los conflictos bélicos.