Scarica il documento per vederlo tutto.
Scarica il documento per vederlo tutto.
Scarica il documento per vederlo tutto.
Scarica il documento per vederlo tutto.
vuoi
o PayPal
tutte le volte che vuoi
Tesina - Premio maturità 2008
Titolo: Balene fuori luogo
Autore: Costanza Formigaro
Descrizione: uso della balena come immagine simbolica di grandezza e potenza in diversi ambiti.
Materie trattate: storia,letteratura inglese,diritto,astronomia.
Area: umanistica
Sommario: Introduzione: Cercando tra le mie passioni una base intorno alla quale costruire ed argomentare questo mio elaborato,ho trovato nell'ambito del mondo dei grandi animali marini una specie che mi ha stupito per la ricchezza di interesse che nel corso dei secoli ha saputo attrarre su di sé: la Balena. Appartenente ai mari di tutto il mondo, Mediterraneo compreso,oltre ad essere il mostro per la mitologia greca, arca per Giona e costellazione equatoriale, raccoglie nella sua mole storie e geografie distanti e differenti, antichi miti e racconti del presente, elementi di realtà e immaginazione. L' immagine della balena assume molto frequentemente un connotato negativo. Probabilmente il fatto che viva in un elemento naturale che non ci appartiene,il mare, fa scattare nell'essere umano il timore che essa sia fonte di pericolo. Le prime leggende riguardanti questo animale risalgono alla civiltà babilonese,la quale rappresentava la balena come il mostro Tiamat,il caos primordiale. Successivamente le vennero attributi svariati nomi e caratteristiche fisiche,rendendola così un vero e proprio mostro degli abissi. Venne identificata tra gli esseri mostruosi : dalla fiera generata il quinto giorno della Creazione da Dio,per governare gli oceani ma poi temuto per la sua potenza: il Leviatano, alla figura della Balena ââ¬" isola ,detta anche Zaratan, rievocata da ecclesiastici, poeti e zoologi del IX secolo. Nel passato: connotazione mitica dell'animale. ïÆ¼ Leggenda dello Zaratan, o Balena ââ¬" isola,risalente alla mitologia germanica e anglosassone. Figura che ricompare in : ï…§ "Le mille e una notte": Sinbad la incontra nel suo primo viaggio; ï…§ "Il libro degli animali",dello zoologo arabo Al-Jahiz, IX secolo; ï…§ "Le Meraviglie della Creazione", del cosmografo persiano Al Qazwini; ï…§ "Navigatio Sancti Brendani", mito irlandese di San Brendano; ï…§ "Orlando Furioso",Ariosto : Astolfo finisce nel ventre di una balena-isola; ïÆ¼ La leggenda del Leviatano riemerge in : ï…§ Il libro di Giona: il suo testo parla del profeta biblico inghiottito da un mostro paragonato ad una balena. Probabilmente però si riferiva al mostro primordiale (simbolo del caos) citato nel libro di Giobbe : il Leviatano.
rilevanza l’episodio biblico di Giona,inghiottito dalla balena dopo essere scappato dalla
Volontà di Dio e rigurgitato sulla costa solo quando il profeta ebbe capito il grave errore
commesso;
la storia di Pinocchio, inizialmente narrata con la figura del pesce-cane dallo scrittore italiano
Carlo Collodi (1826-1890) e successivamente rivista dall’azienda di animazione Walt Disney
con quella della balena, che riprende l’insegnamento biblico citato precedentemente; Jona che
Nel 1993 anche la cinematografia recente riprende il concetto simbolico con il film
visse nella Balena,del regista Roberto Faenza,che racconta le disavventure di un bambino
nell'orrore dei campi di sterminio nazisti, ai quali sopravvive ma in cui perde padre e madre.
In questo contesto Giona si trasforma nell'incarnazione dell'intero popolo ebraico, costretto a
restare “nel ventre della balena”, cioè in un mondo ostile che cerca di opprimerlo o addirittura
di distruggerlo, ma, con tenacia e forza d'animo, riuscirà ad essere “vomitato” dal mostro e a
tornare alla vita.
La tradizione del mostro marino che inghiotte il bambino risale a riti di popolazioni antiche: in
Australia si era soliti allestire cavità nella terra,sul davanti della quale veniva sistemato un
tronco d’albero che raffigurava le fauci; nell’ex Nuova Guinea tedesca invece per la
circoncisione veniva costruita una casa speciale: doveva rappresentare il mostro Barlum che
inghiotte i bambini. La tribù Jabim poneva una palma come trave superiore,le cui radici e
foglie dovevano richiamare i capelli del mostro e un graticcio di foglie di cocco dipinto a
macchie al posto dell’ingresso della capanna simulava invece le fauci. La capanna andava via
via sempre più stretta e bassa,riproponendo così la forma del mostro,fino ad arrivare alla
coda. Anche l’interno richiamava il ventre del mostro: nella capanna risuonava l’eco della voce
di Barlum.
Nell’età contemporanea l’idea della balena come spietato assassino rimane: il romanzo che
Moby Dick,
meglio espone questo pensiero è dello scrittore americano Herman Melville
(1851).
Qui l’imponente capodoglio bianco incarna la figura del Leviatano,poiché per le sue immense
dimensioni e la spaventosa forza è, secondo l’autore, la specie che meglio richiama l’immagine
mitica.
Anche l’economista Thomas Hobbes si avvale di questa figura biblica per rappresentare la
forza dello stato autoritario.
In Italia un’ altra situazione viene raffigurata con una balena: il partito della Democrazia
Cristiana.
I richiami a balene non si fermano solo al mondo terreno,tra politica e letteratura, ma anche
alla sfera celeste con la Costellazione della Balena,posta nell’emisfero australe, che viene
collegata al mito greco di Andromeda.
DIRITTO
“Leviathan”
Leviathan is not only the Biblical sea monster referred to in the Testament, but also the title of an
economical book. The author of Leviathan is Thomas Hobbes and the outrageous animal
represents the power of the State.
The natural law philosopher Thomas Hobbes lived during some of the most tumultuous times in
European history (consequently, it should be no surprise that his theories were thoroughly
pessimistic regarding human nature).
Born near Malmesbury, the early death of his father brought young Thomas Hobbes under the
care of his wealthy uncle. At the age of fourteen, he entered Magdalen College, Oxford, and took
his B.A. five years later. After his first tour of Europe in 1610, he made the acquaintance of Francis
Bacon. However, he only became converted to the scientific outlook in the 1630s, after being
seduced by Euclid's Geometry and hobnobbing with European scientists during a tour of the
continent.
Hobbes was particularly entranced by Galileo's reverse vision of dynamics.
After meeting Galileo in 1636, Hobbes sought to apply this idea to a comprehensive social
philosophy. He envisioned this in three parts. In the first part, of Body, he would relate the general
laws of motion; in the second, of Man, he would show how humans can be considered bodies in
motion (motivated by sensations, desires, appetites, etc.) and how they are impacted by external
motions; in the third part, of the Citizen, he would give the results of these dynamic human
interactions on the body politic.
In 1642, Hobbes's De Cive came out, a more detailed and formal analysis of the third part of his
scheme. Seeing that it had little impact in England, Hobbes set out writing a new treatise which
would explain his theory in a more down-to-earth manner. The result was Leviathan (1651).
Leviathan (1651) was clearly Hobbes's masterpiece. In it, Hobbes set out his doctrine of the
foundation of societies and legitimate governments.
Leviathan was written during the English Civil War; much of the book is occupied with
demonstrating the necessity of a strong central authority to avoid the evil of discord and civil war.
Hobbes postulates what life would be like without government, a condition which he calls the
state of nature. In that state, each person would have a right, or license, to everything in the
world. This inevitably leads to conflict, a war of all against all (bellum omnium contra omnes), and
thus lives that are "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short" (XIII).
But war is not in man's best interest. According to Hobbes, man has a self-interested and
materialistic desire to end war :
"the passions that incline men to peace are fear of death, desire of such things as are necessary to
commodious living, and a hope by their industry to obtain them" (XIII, 14).
He forms peaceful societies by entering into a social contract.
According to Hobbes, society is a population beneath an authority, to whom all individuals in that
society covenant just enough of their natural right for the authority to be able to ensure internal
peace and a common defence. This sovereign, whether monarchy, aristocracy or democracy
(though Hobbes prefers monarchy), should be a Leviathan, an absolute authority.
Law, for Hobbes, is the enforcement of contracts.
Hobbes' Leviathan state is still authoritative in matters of aggression, one man waging war on
another or any matters pertaining to the cohesiveness of the state. It should say nothing about
what any man does otherwise; so long as one man does not harm another, the sovereign should
keep its hands off him.
In actuality, however, the extent to which this sovereign may exercise this authority is conditioned
by the sovereign's obligations to natural law. Although the sovereign has no legislative obligations,
it is more beneficial for him to abide by those laws which prescribe peace for security (the laws of
nature). Thus this conditions the authority of the sovereign with a prudential morality, or, more
accurately, a moral obligation. A sovereign also maintains equality within the state, since the
common people would be "washed out" in the glare of their sovereign; Hobbes compares this
"washing out" of the common people in their sovereign's presence to the fading of the stars in the
presence of the sun.
In essence, Hobbes' political doctrine is "do no harm."
In chapter XV, 35, reads:
"Do not that to another, which thou wouldst not have done to thyself."
In Leviathan, Hobbes explicitly states that the sovereign has authority to assert power over
matters of faith and doctrine, and that if he does not do so, he invites discord. Hobbes presents his
own religious theory, but states that he would defer to the will of the sovereign as to whether his
theory was acceptable.
Thomas Hobbes also touched upon the sovereign's ability to tax in Leviathan, although he is not as
widely cited for his economic theories as he is for his political theories. Hobbes said:
"Equal justice includes the equal imposition of taxes. The equality of taxes doesn’t depend on
equality of wealth, but on the equality of the debt that every man owes to the commonwealth for
his defence."
Put simply, Hobbes believed that taxes were necessary to support the military and that the
military was necessary to enforce the rule of law. Thus, Hobbes saw taxes only as a necessary
support of the rule of law.
With the citation of the philosopher Hobbes we can see the beast Leviathan is connected not to
the god’s power but to the power of an authoritarian state.
This Leviathan has the power with a positive connotation: under his laws people can live in safety.
Bibliography:
Appunti e fotocopie fornite dalla professoressa K. Parker;
• http://it.wikipedia.org;
• http://publicliterature.org;
• http://oregonstate.edu.
•
English literature
Moby Dick
One of the most popular image of whales can be found in a notorious American novel, written in
1851 by Herman Melville: Moby Dick.
Melville’s career faded after the publication of the book and he was actually considered a failure
when he passed away in 1891. Fortunately, his work has been widely recognized since then and
Melville has taken his place amongst the literary giants.
Moby-Dick recounts the adventures of the narrator Ishmael as he sails on the whaling ship Pequot
under the command of Captain Ahab. Ishmael soon learns that Ahab seeks one specific whale,
Moby Dick ,which destroyed Ahab’s boat and bit off his leg.
The very mentioned Leviathan is incarnate in the Sperm Whale, because of is the best animal to
represent the mythological figure. He has an exceptional strength and a “cruel intelligence”.
This Leviathan has a negative description: he is seen as the terrible whale that haunts Ahab. He’s
like a spirit: Moby Dick is always present but appears only in the last three chapters, in which the
book gives account of the chase.
Moby Dick is a Sperm Whale with a white hump and his temperament is told in several legends.
Only few whalers have seen the White Whale but everybody know he has the gift of ubiquity and
immortality. He has an unusually intelligence, resorting to many clever stratagems to defeat Ahab
and crew that a normal whale would never be capable of. He also seems to be capable of using his
injuries to great advantage, as initially foretold when he slices Ahab's leg off with his lower jaw;
later on, during the first day of the chase, he wedges the same jaw into Ahab's whaleboat to trap
it, gently shakes it to terrify the crew, then snaps the boat in half and dumps Ahab into the water
(before swimming in circles around the captain in order to cut him off from his crewmates.) On the
second day, he allows Ahab and his men to strike him with their harpoons during a head-on
charge; he then swims around wildly to entangle the harpoons before yanking Ahab towards him
in order to cut him up with the harpoons embedded in his flesh.
In the chapter about his description, Melville shows the whale as :
“… a Sperm Whale of uncommon magnitude and malignity… Moby Dick was ubiquitous… he had
actually been encountered in opposite latitudes at one and the same instant of time…was immortal
(for immortality is but ubiquity in time)… it was not so much his uncommon bulk that so much
distinguished him from other Sperm Whale… Nor was it his unwonted magnitude, nor his
remarkable hue, nor yet his deformed lower jaw, that so much invested the whale with natural
terror, as that unexampled, intelligent malignity… his treacherous retreats struck more of dismay
than perhaps aught else… when swimming before his exulting pursuers, with every apparent
symptom of alarm, he had several times been known to turn around suddenly, and, bearing down
upon them, either stave their boats to splinters, or drive them back in consternation to their ship…”
(Chapter XLI, Moby Dick)
The Ahab’s hate towards Moby Dick born when the whale bit off his leg. After that the Captain
feels a desire of revenge. His hate soon becomes an identification of all his physical and
psychological problems in Moby Dick.
“…He piled upon the whale's white hump the sum of all the general rage and hate felt by his whole
race from Adam down…”
“He was intent on an audacious, immitigable, and supernatural revenge. Here, then, was this grey-