PACKED COLUMNS
With that type of columns we have a continuous contact between vapor and liquid phases.
With the every column the phases haven't enough time to have an efficient mass transfer, so we fill the column with materials which increase the surface contact between the liquid and the vapor.
In separation columns, the mass and energy transfer between phases is strictly related to the contact surface. There are 3 main types of liquid-vapor contact:
Vapor dispersion in the liquid (continuous phase) in the form of bubbles or foam; this is the case of tray columns or bubble columns.
Liquid dispersion in the vapor (continuous phase) in the form of drops, as in the case of spray columns.
Spreading of the liquid in the form of a film immersed in the vapor; this is what happens inside the packed columns, where the packing acts like a support for the liquid film. In this case both phases are continuous.
TYPES OF PACKINGS
Two types of packings are available: Random packings
Structured packings
To ensure effective contact between liquid and vapor the packings must have the following characteristics:
- A high value of surface area per unit of volume in order to maximize the interface area
- Low pressure drops, to enable high liquid and vapor flow rates per unit cross-sectional area of the column without high compression phenomena. This required a high void fraction of the packings
- Corrosion resistance
- Good mechanical properties
- Quite low costs
The liquid is delivered to the packing material through a distributor. It is distributed on the packing surface and flows downwards. The vapor gas rises upwards touching the liquid film.
Random packings => ex. Raschig rings, eesening tups, Pall tups
The performance depends on -Type of packings
-Dimensions
-Materials
Structured packings => ex. Rachig rings, plastic grids
HYDRODYNAMICS OF A PACKED COLUMN
So we have a liquid flux in the form of a film that descends along the packing's surface and a vapor phase as a continuous phase that ascends through the packing's voids
The liquid film should wet as much packing's surface as possible
OPERATION LIMITS
- The UPPER LIMIT of the column's operability range is represented by column flooding. This is characterized by a partial or total clogging of the liquid in the column, and the consequent sudden increase in pressure drops
- The vapor prevents the liquid from descending, until it exits from the overhead vapor pipe
- The LOWER LIMIT, named loading, is represented by the point under which there is sufficient contact between liquid and vapor. This depends not only on the vapor velocity, but mostly on the liquid flowrate
The figure shows the hydrodynamic behaviour of the packings in terms of pressure drops per unit height of packing as a function of the vapor and liquid "interface velocity"
uV = VV/A uL = LV/A (uV,i = VV/AE)
A-B } at low liquid flow rate vapor remains below interface at with the square of the gas velocity
B-C } if the vapor velocity increases at a certain point, liquid and vapor begin to interact due to friction, the liquid film begins to thicken, further reducing the section through which the vapor can pass, and there fore increasing its velocity too
This condition is called LOADING
C-D } further increasing uv the channels are progressively clogged, the vapor bubbles in the liquid and the column begins to clog (FLOODING)
With more liquid (u'L > uL) everything is corrected but at lower vapor flow rates
PACKINGS WETTING
The correct operation range of a packed column is between loading and flooding. That is the first condition to verify
However, once the diameter has been sized, the ceeting condition must also be checked
The packing wetting increases almost continuously with the liquid flow rate. For random packings it is assumed that the packing is sufficiently wet when the wetting rate WR is greater than the minimum value called minimum wetting rate MWR
WR = Lv/A / a = [m2/h]
a = Packing specific surface [m2/m3]
MWR = Lv/Amax / a
Lv/A = a WR = [m3/(m2 h)]
Lv/Amax = a MWR
Random packings: MWR = 0.08 m2/h for dp < 75 mm
= 0.12 m2/h for dp > 75 mm
dp = packing nominal dimension
Structured packings: the minimum liquid flow (velocity) is directly provided
Material
Ui,min. (m3h-1)m-1
Raw ceramic (unglazed) 0.5
Oxidized metal (C steel, copper) 0.75
Stainless steel with scratched surface 1
Glazed ceramic 2
Glass 2.5
Polished metal (stainless steel, titanium etc.) 3
PVC-CPVC 3.5
Polypropylene 4
Fluoropolymers (like TEFLON) 5
Design and rating of the character for random packings
The method used to evaluate the flooding condition in design and rating of random packed columns is the empirical one proposed by Eckert.
K = mass velocity { (Vp/A)2 Cf (rhoe/rhyou)0.2 (rhoh2o/rhoe) } / g rhoe Pe
By the graph we obtain K = so (Vp/A)p ? minimum area we need to have
H2O (20C) = 1 cP = 0.001 Pa*s
rhoH2O (20C) = 1000 kg/m3
g = 9.81 m/s2
Therefore, we calculate the flow parameter as: Flv = Lv/Vv sqrt(rhoL/rhoV)
From the Eckert diagram the K value is determined.
The mass flooding velocity is calculated as: (Vp/A)e = sqrt(keq rhoe / Cf(re/rhe)3/2(rhoi/pe))
In design we have to set Cf
Diameter design for random packings
Firstly, it is necessary to select the packing (type, size and material).
After that:
- The mass flooding velocity (Vp/A)fl is calculated as seen before;
- The mass velocity of the vapor is calculated considering an adequate K5 value:(Vp/A) = K5(Vp/A)fl
- The area is calculated: A = Vp/(Vp/A) and the diameter: D = √(4A/π)
- A commercial value of D is selected, and A is calculated again;
- With the new value of the area, the value of K5 is calculated again, and checked that it is less than 80%;
- The value of the pressure drops per unit of height is calculated, knowing both the value of Flv and K.
Diameter rating for random packings
In this case the type, size and material of the packing are known, together with the diameter (area) of the column. Therefore:
- The mass flooding velocity is calculated as seen before;
- Knowing the effective mass velocity, the value of K5 is calculated and it is verified that it is less than 80%:K5 = (Vp/A)/((Vp/A)fl) = √(K/Kfl)
- The corresponding value of K is calculated:K = ((Vp/A)2Cf(mul/muH2O)0.2(rhoH2O/rhol))/(g rhovrhol)
- The value of the pressure drops per unit of height is calculated, knowing both the value of Flv and K.
Design and rating of the diameter for structured packings
For structured packings, the GPDC-KG diagram (Generalized Pressure Drop Correlation) proposed by Kister and Gill is used to calculate the flooding rate.
The capacity parameter is defined as:
Y = uv sqrt((rhov/(rhol - rhov)) Cf0,5 vl0,05
vl = mul / rhol
The flooding curve is given by:
(DeltaP / L)fl = 4,17 Cf0,7
SUO- Prof. Elena Barbera
20
Structured packings table
Packing Type Cf, m-1
- Koch-Sulzer CY 230
- Koch-Sulzer BX 69
- Mellapak Sulzer (metal) 500Y 112
- Mellapak Sulzer (metal) 350Y 75
- Mellapak Sulzer (metal) 250Y 66
- Mellapak Sulzer (metal) 125Y 33
- Mellapak Sulzer (plastics) 250Y 72
- Flexipak Koch #1 98
- Flexipak Koch #2 43
- Flexipak Koch #3 26
- Flexipak Koch #4 20
- Flexeramic Koch #28 131
- Flexeramic Koch #48 79
- Flexeramic Koch #88 49
- Gempak Glitsch 4A 105
- Gempak Glitsch 3A 69
- Gempak Glitsch 2A 52
- Gempak Glitsch 1,5A 39
- Gempak Glitsch 1A 30
- Gempak Glitsch 0,5A 20
- Montz B - 1 300 108
- Montz B - 1 250 66
- Intalox (structured) Norton 1T 66
- Intalox (structured) Norton 2T 56
- Intalox (structured) Norton 3T 43
- Jaeger MacPac 39
Cf is the packing parameter. It is determined experimentally, and it is a function of the shape, size and material of the packing.
SUO- Prof. Elena Barbera
21