Method applied to the system with constant relative volatilities + constant molar flow rates in the two column sections
That method are based on the concept of key component(s)
The lightest component is called LIGHT-KEY component - is the lightest one present in the residue with an appreciable concentration so the lighter components than the light-key are all only in the distillate
The heaviest component is the HEAVY-KEY component
is the heaviest one present in the distillate with an appreciable concentration so the heavier components than the heavy-key are all only in the residue
Composition & temperature profiles in a distillation column
Distillation of a quaternary mixture:
n-C4, i-C5, n-C5, n-C6
- The temperature always increases from top to bottom
- The composition profiles of intermediate components have a maximum
- Non-key components are separated in few stages, then behave as inerts
core position of i-C5 is increasing to the top
Light-key: i-C5
Heavy-key: n-C5
nC4 is only present in the distillate
nC6 is only in the residue
T from top to bottom
Discontinuity of T and composition profile due to the feed stage
Effect of pressure on distillation column profiles
Distillation of a benzene-toluene mixture at P=0.1atm and at P=1 atm
Example at atmospheric pressure and under vacuum
At lower pressure the T-x-y curve is shifted to lower values
and about the concentration we have an effect on relative volatily
At lower pressure the extent of separation is larger
with the same number of stages > higher purity at the outlet at lower pressure
We change pressure (at higher values, for example) bc of the costs of utilities, at condenser and reboiler
At the reboiler we could have: low pressure steam
5-6 bar, 150C
medium pressure steam
15 bar, 200C
high pressure steam
40 bar, 250 C
COSTS
At the condenser we could have: cooling water
15-20 C
Refugeated water
5 °C
Refugeated cycle
COSTS
When we have very high BODs retained, then it could be convenient to operate under vacuum
We want life to have T low at the reboiler and high at the condenser
ENERGY INTEGRATION
We don't integrate the reboiler with the condenser because the temperature at that element is not the same even if we supply or remove a similar amount of heat
When we have a preheated feed, the duty at the reboiler increased with partially vaporized feed, the duty at the reboiler is lower, bc the feed is hotter and this is beneficial for the processSo we can exploit the sensible (hot) to preheat the feed
Energy balance around the heat exchanger
F'jF' + RjR = R'jR' + FjF
F(jF - jF') = R(jR - jR')
F(TF - TF') = R(TR - TR')
We find TFand we can find QFand solve relative of the energy balances of the column
Q constant
We impose that TR' = TF' + 15°CΔT > 15°C
in order for the heat exchange to be effective, there must be a minimum temperature difference between the hot feed (residue) and the cooled feed (feed)
In that way we reduce the size of the heat exchangerNOT lower than 15°C/10°C
Reflux subcooling
NOT NOW
It is possible to distinguish:
- External reflux rate: re = Le/D
- Internal reflux rate: r = L/D
Resulting in: Ve = Le + D and V = L + D
The relationship between Ve and V is similar to the one of the subcooled feed:
Ve - V = Le - L = φLeLe
φLe = - cp,L/λ (Tb,Le - TLe)
So, the relationship between the two reflux rate is: r = re(1 - φLe)
The number of stages are identified with the usual construction, considering the internal reflux rate in for the enrichment line.
The subcooled reflux, entered in the column, needs heat to be thermally equilibrated to the boiling temperature (natural top conditions)
Part from vapor flow rate will condense
L != Le -> L > Le
V != Ve -> V > Ve
We need L and V to use in rectif - Thee re-concentration
φCE has the same meaning of degree of vaporization but for Le
φCE = (V - V')/F
F -> LeV -> VeV' -> V
φCE = (Ve - V)/Le
Ve - V = φCELe = Le - L -> Le(1 - φCE) = L
φCE is calculated with Energy Balance
Le qce(Tb,ce - Tce) = l(V - Ve)
qce = - Cp,l / l (Tb,lce - Tce) negative -> subcooled
So x = xe(l - qce)
If the reflux is subcooled we will have an internal reflux ratio will be larger, consequently all the theoretical stages will be larger, so
Qc = l Ve + Ve cp,l(Tb,l - Tb) it increases
total flow rate
→ reflux to reboile
At the reboller ↑ composition of energy (Bcof ↑ flowrates)
Azeotrope: strategies to overcome the azeotrope and continue with the separation
only valid
if the composition of azeotrope is really affected by the pressure (composition will vary)
Special distillation processes for (near)azeotropic systems
1. Pressure swing distillation.
If the composition of the azeotrope is markedly affected by pressure two columns in series can be used in such a way that the feed composition is in between the azeotropic compositions at the two operating pressures. This is rarely the case in the industrial practice, which requires operating pressures not too high (not more than 50 bar as a reference). One remarkable example of pressure swing distillation is the separation of H2O-HCl mixtures.
SUO- Prof. Elena Barbera
10
CHANGE OF VOLATILITY
P1
P2
feed 1 condenser
feed 2 condenser
xa1 = ya1
P2
xa2 = ya2
P1
zF
F, zF
pre-
change
comp. 2
heavy
comp. 1
heavy
Special distillation processes for (near)azeotropic systems
2. Distillation of aqueous azeotropes by salt addition.
This idea is based in the so-called salting-out effect, a property by which the presence of a salt in the initial mixture is able to break the azeotrope between two mixture components. A very well-known example is the possibility to break the water-ethanol azeotrope by using NaCl. Unfortunately, this possibility is rarely exploited owing to the complications (i.e. crystallization and corrosion problems) caused by the introduction on purpose of a salt in a chemical process.
SUO- Prof. Elena Barbera
12
Test carbon:
Special distillation processes for (near) azeotropic systems
3. Extractive distillation
In this case a liquid solvent is fed to the distillation column, at a different stage from the feed to be fractionated, in order to break the azeotrope. Such an effect can be achieved thanks to a selective interaction of this solvent with the mixture components. In other words, the solvent modifies the activity coefficients of the components to be separated and is able to increase the volatility of one with respect to the other enough to enable a distillation between them. A second column is needed to separate and recycle the solvent. In the chemical industry, extractive distillation is the preferred technique to obtain the separation of an azeotropic mixture.
Special distillation processes for (near) azeotropic systems
Extractive distillation process scheme
Make-up
Solvent
Feed
Distillate 1
Distillate 2
Solvent recycle
Ethy-water
Special distillation processes for (near)azeotropic systems
4. Azeotropic distillation
Similarly to extractive distillation, an extra-component i.e. a solvent is added to the process also in this case. However, the required property is that it is able to create a multicomponent (usually with higher volatility) azeotropic mixture where the pseudo-binary composition of the two components to be distilled is different from the corresponding azeotropic one. A classical example of azeotropic distillation is the production of pure ethanol from a water-ethanol mixture close to its azeotrope (90% by mole of ethanol) by using benzene as the solvent. This process scheme is a little bit more complicated than for extractive distillation as it involves not only vapor liquid equilibria but also vapor-liquid-liquid equilibria.
Special distillation processes for (near)azeotropic systems
Azeotropic distillation process scheme
FEED
89% E
11% W
Benzene
MAKEUP
24% E
22% W
54% B
35% E
61% W
4% B
49% E
51% W
89% E
11% W
Ethanol
Water
Batch Distillation Process
It used when random quantities of mixtures must be fractionated
The operation can take place in 3 distinct ways: operation with
- Total reflux (fully batch)
- Constant reflux and variable composition of the distillate (semi-batch)
- Constant composition of the distillate and variable reflux (semi-batch)
Material balance
Assumption: we don't have accumulation of liquid inside the column, but only into the two tanks (pseudo steady state conditions)
F (kmol) is divided between the reboiler and the head accumulator (located after the condenser)
Here the reflux is collected and it is used to guarantee a constant reflux
After the start-up phase (filling of the trays) the column is operated at total reflux => D and R are constant (kmol) in terms of amount
Over time the head capacity becomes enriched with light component and the bottom capacity with the heavy one - when the specification for both products is reached then the operation stops
Overall material balances at any time:
- F = D + R
- F zF = D xD + R xR
We set xD and xR, also D and R are fixed
D/F = (zF - xR,spec) / (xD,spec - xR,spec) or R/F = (xD,spec - zF) / (xD,spec - xR,spec)
We obtain Dspec, Rspec
The final composition x0 and xR depend on how the feed is divided between D and R
If D < Dspec the bottom product will be contaminated by the light component
If D > Dspec the head product will be contaminated by the heavy component
Mc-Cabe Thiele Plot
Material balance around the upper section:
D = N-out reflux tank
dD/dt = V - L (=> flow rates)